Sure, to a certain extent I agree with you. I am not saying progress hasn’t been made. For me, I have been in situations where my Phonaks have performed really well in noise. I was at a wedding a couple of months back, and I was astonished that I could hear and have a conversation with a couple of friends when the surrounding music was 100db+. The problem is that there have been other situations where I have not been so lucky, particularly in pubs with 6+ people talking quickly. I am not sure what it is about these other environments, whether it be just the pace of the conversation, the number of talkers, the presence of music, or what.
My concern is that we are getting caught up with features like rechargeables, MFI, android connectivity etc… which whilst very important, are not as important for me as being able to be confident in all environments and conversing with people. I have seen the claims about AutoSense 3.0 from Phonak and a “60% speech improvement”. These are impressive claims, but we don’t know the benchmark to start off with. A 60% improvement over what? And in what environments? I think the phrase smoke and mirrors comes in here. There used to be a lot of literature about signal to noise ratios, beamforming, improvements in noise etc, but these seem to be replaced with stuff like mobile phone connectivity, which I find absolutely bewildering. Yes, it’s great that I can communicate on the phone, but that’s only 5% of my day. What else is going on?