iPhone vs Android

android
bluetooth
iphone

#164

I can understand what you are saying, but now that I am retired, my cell phone is my lifeline. We no longer have a landline and I cannot hear over a house phone anyway. I go hiking and I explore the area that I have adopted as my home. So my cell became my way to get help if needed and my wife can contact me even when I am in the woods or at one of the lakes. And heaven forbid that I have an accident I can get help, the GPS is wonderful for find things and even me if I get lost.


#165

Did I not say that there are positive aspects and one cannot get along without them in today’s society? It’s accessibility that I was addressing and that was qualified by “at least until I retire”. For me, cell phones are both a blessing and a curse. Milos suggestion “Then stop using them. Simple as that” just tells me he wasn’t paying attention.


#166

I have worked jobs that I carried at least two cell phones and any where from one to three pagers at the same time. So I fully understand your feelings. When I was on call I covered as many as five departments at once. And have had the times that all of them needed help at once even with having several backups. It isn’t fun for anyone that has good hearing much less someone with very bad hearing.


#167

I use Cala 8 HAs (for 2 years now), and have had absolutely no problems with iPhone 7+ connectivity.


#168

Hi Keithr,
I’m very pleased to hear that you have finally found an Android solution! How have you found the Phonak Marvel HAs in terms of longevity during the day? Are you able to get 4 or 5 hours streaming out of them or are they dead by the evening?
Also, how good are the android phone apps for HAs? The user reviews on the Google play store make for depressing reading… I suspect that the iPhone equivalent is much more stable and has greater functionality? And yes I’ve put my money where my mouth is and bought an iPhone 7+ even though I own a Galaxy S6… Just for the connectivity with HAs. More fool me probably… What has your experience been?
Thanks!
Susie


#169

App reviews aren’t very meaningful as people who write reviews don’t take the time to read about how the app is supposed to work.


#170

The Marvel app doesn’t do a whole lot, but works okay. I can adjust each aid’s volume independently if need be. I was able to adjust the outside mic volume during streaming, which was handy. I could use it to change programs, but I don’t have any. That’s pretty much it.


#171

I’ll add my opinion. Some background. I’ve actually worked for one of the aforementioned tech companies. I’ve use iPhone, Blackberry 10, Android, Linux, Windows, BSD.

Each ecosystem has it’s features benefits and drawbacks, along with elements that are proprietary and elements that are open and based on standards.

Often, it’s to differentiate the product. Sometimes it’s an annoyance to some and a benefit to others.

I’d say Blackberry 10 was a great phone OS but ultimately it failed. Back in 2007 the iPhone was a far better experience than the early Android phones.

I currently use Android. I’d use an iPhone too. Cost wise my current handset (Huawei P20) is a good bang for the buck option.

Eventually as time goes by, the connectivity will become standard and the argument will be pointless. Like anything, early adopters will pay for that privilege. Anyone remember Minidisc or BetaMax?

Buy what works for you. I’m informed enough to make my own choices. It doesn’t matter what phone you use - if you buy a high end android or a newer iPhone, the experience should be a good one.

I use normal headphones with my phone. Couldn’t care less about streaming. If HAs do their job properly, the direct streaming isn’t important.

What needs to happens is an open-standard. The MFI is nice, but it needs to be opened up for all handset providers to work with it. This won’t happen but for uses such as this, perhaps legislation needs looking into to force it to happen.


#172

The only thing I disagree with. Streaming, for me, means better word discrimination. Sound/words coming from small cheap speakers is not as easy to understand as those same words transmitted.

Also, I think MFi is dead. Phonak has proven they can use standard Bluetooth for direct connect so now I think that R&D money in the other HA companies will go for their own version of direct connect to all devices. Why limit it to iPhone when Android has 80% of the market.


#173

Yeah, I think you’re right. That sentence was poorly worded.

What I should have said was that streaming shouldn’t be an excuse for HAs not to allow normal listening.

I do appreciate that some have a greater need for streaming than others.

Point taken.


#174

I personally would love the see universe hearing aid connection too. It would be nice if I could connect my aids to my Samsung note 8 so she could hand off a call to me.


#175

You can. Phonak Marvel does that.


#176

I have new aids already as part of my VA disability, Oticon OPN1 ITE half shell


#177

Hi Susie,

BlueCrab is right. I have had problems a few times with the app freezing up or refusing to connect to the hearing aids. Just closing the program and restarted it fixed it every time, however.

The main functions are just as he described. I have used mine to change programs, and it works fine. When you stream using the built-in AutoSense program, it switches to Bluetooth streaming and an icon appears below the volume slider. Tapping the icon allows you to adjust the balance between surrounding sounds and audio. The Help says “Some programs can contain more options than just the volume control. If options are available, a button below the main volume control appears.” I have only seen the button when streaming; the two programs my audiologist set up do not display the button, so I have no experience with that.

Besides the main app screen, there is a Settings icon, which displays just “App settings,” “My hearing aids,” “FAQ,” and “Feedback.” The app settings allow you to enable demo mode or enable or disable sending of usage data to Phonak; that’s it. “My hearing aids” just lists your programs and allows you to change their names.

So yes, the app (Remote) is very basic (I don’t know how it compares to the iPhone version), but it does what I need it to do. Streaming of music and TV (with the TV Connector) work beautifully, and I love not needing an iPhone to be able to stream.

There is another app, myPhonak, that allows your audiologist to adjust your hearing aid settings remotely, which he doesn’t think I need because he’s so close. I need an invitation from him to be able to use it, but it has some other features I’d like to try, so I’m going to try to convince him to enable it next visit. It says I can provide feedback and “communicate” with him, including seeing and talking with him. The Google Play description doesn’t mention it, but I read somewhere that it allows “journaling,” and I’m curious to see what that is.

As far as batteries, I don’t have the rechargeable model, but use 312 batteries. I have had no problems with longevity. I get up to 5 days of battery life. When I stream a lot it’s less (I haven’t tested extensively, but I think 2 or 3 days at least). I certainly have no problem with them dying at the end of the day.

I don’t know if I mentioned in my earlier post that I was almost in your situation. When I found out about the Marvels, I was within a few days of buying an iPhone XR as soon as it was released. I hope things work out for you with your two phones. When you get your Marvels, I’ll be interesting to hear how the iPhone and Android connectivity compares.


#178

Wow, only two replies were displaying for me when I posted just now. I can see now that you got a lot of responses; I’m curious to see what I can learn from them!


#179

Thanks for thoughts davart,
Very helpful. I’m 55 so yes, I remember such systems as betamax lol. I was a betamax buyer myself, and paid the price when vhs railroaded it. Same with many other tech, I go for what I consider to be the better tech, only to find that the ‘cheap and nasty but it does the job’ version wins the day… I’m all for open stds so I adopted android when it came to a choice between the two main players in the phone industry (Android or iPhone). A few yours later and Windows is a mess! OK, it’s always been a mess but just even more so… Windows 10 comes along and totally trashes my pc… I vow I’ll never touch another pc at home (obviously have to at work…) and buy an Mac Pro (my 1st Apple product), then a couple of iPads. So I now have mixed platforms (PC / Android and Mac / iOS). I’m heavily into playing Elite Dangerous (its a space sim game) and guess what - v2 (Horizons update) only runs on a ruddy PC :open_mouth: :astonished::astonished: :face_with_symbols_over_mouth::face_with_symbols_over_mouth::face_with_symbols_over_mouth:
So I bought a PC again against my better judgement…
Meanwhile, I’ve stuck with Android because iPhone didn’t have a killer app to justify the extra £££/$$$ for their phones. With the possible except of the Phonak Marvel’s, I think that is pretty much the situation now though with buying a new pair of HAs… If I want choice, a iPhone is going to be necessary…

TL;DR

As I’m now 55, I’ve hit the problem of competing tech many times and fallen foul of it just as often. One or the other always seem to lead for a while, and then you have a killer app situation that forces change upon you. HAs are no different. And despite the Marvel that is the Phonak Marvel, I would like a choice of more than one.


#180

Hi Keithr,
Thank you for the very detailed response about your Marvel HAs and the app functionality. That’s most helpful to know! As I suspected, it’s the working minimum… Keyword there is WORKING! So despite its limitations, it sounds as if you made a good call there!
Going with the non-rechargable std battery format was probably a good move too, as I suspect that the rechargeable versions run out of power by the evening when you want to site down and stream from the TV or other device.
I’m not 100% I’ll buy into the Phonak Marvel yet, I may do, but I’d like to hear what the iPhone experience with the Marvel HAs is like for comparison first if possible … Hopefully some one here will be able to post on that one!
Thanks again for the detailed post!
Susie
PS if it were possible to give you more than 1 thumbs up I would! :blush:


#181

Well I am 71 and have fought through all of the different computers, and devices along the way. To be honest a lot of the ones that didn’t make it are better than the ones that did. It all comes down to advertisement and what little niche it fills. I am not saying android is bad, it isn’t I just don’t use it now, I once did and had some bad experiences with crappy hardware. Yes I now use iPhone it is doing what I wish it to do, and at my age I don’t have to relearn every time there is an update or I need a new device. The same is true for the MacOS. My only advice is find what works for you an go with it.


#182

Hi cvkemp.
It sounds like you have decades of experience to draw upon! I haven’t fired up my Mac Pro for a while now (but I definitely should - if only to update it!!). With the iPhone in the post, I got another hearing test this morning and requested a quote for the Phonak Marvel 312 (I forgot to specify M90s) but hopefully the guy will get the quotes for all of the various model options…
I’ll update you how I get on :face_with_raised_eyebrow:


#183

Thanks, Susanna. :grinning:

Yes, that’s exactly why I didn’t get the rechargeable model. I just didn’t feel that I could depend on my hearing aids still working at the end of the day.

I have been very interested in the “hybrid” rechargeables that I’ve read about here that allow you to use regular batteries if you run out of charge. If those were available, I’m pretty sure that’s the direction I would have gone.